The investment rating of Maruti Suzuki India Ltd has been revised to a Hold, following a reevaluation of the firm’s overall investment attractiveness. This rating change is based on a blend of both mixed technical signals and financial performance indicators, compared to the historically good fundamentals and market performance of the company.
Operational efficiency and valuation perspective
This low gearing ratio has been considered a source of strength, particularly in a cyclical industry such as the automobile industry, where businesses are vulnerable to massive fluctuations in demand and profits. The net sales and operating profit of the business are recorded to have increased at annualised rates of 21.05% and 55.33% respectively, over the long term, which indicates continuous improvement in the revenue and operational efficiency of the business. The Return on Equity (ROE) is a decent 14.8%, which is a sign of good use of shareholders’ capital.
Irrespective of these good things, recent quarterly performances have indicated some earnings stagnation. Before tax (other income omitted), the latest quarter under review showed a 6.2% reduction in profit before tax to ₹3,393.10 crores, which reflects a slowdown in earnings that is the opposite trend to the company’s historical trends. This has cast doubts on the immediate growth trend, especially with the half-year inventory and debtor turnover ratios of 1.40 times and 2.08 times, respectively, suggesting that there may be some inefficiency in the working capital management.
Valuation-wise, the stock of Maruti Suzuki is fairly priced in accordance with past trends and industries of the same kind, whereby the Price-to-Book (P/B) ratio stands at 5.2. Nevertheless, the Price/Earnings Growth (PEG) ratio, which stands at 6.5, indicates that the stock is trading at the upper end of its valuation compared to its current low growth levels of 5.4% in the last year.
Though the high PEG ratio may represent the investor’s faith in the future growth prospects, it also shows the high expectations that the present financial performance has not yet proven. The company has a large institutional investor of 38.42%, which is indicative that even with the mixed signals, large, sophisticated market players continue to have confidence in the company. The valuation situation would then create a situation in which the price of the stock would be based on optimism, which could not be entirely consistent with the short-term fundamentals.
Technical and financial performance
Maruti Suzuki stock is a good performer in the long term, and it has been able to perform better than benchmark indices such as the Sensex. In a period of over one year, the stock has given 51.14% returns against the Sensex’s 7.62% and in a period of over ten years, its 256.66% returns are by far surpassing the 224.76% returns of the Sensex. These statistics highlight the high franchise of the firm and the capacity to attract high returns to investors in the long term.
The current financial trend is more pessimistic. The deceleration of growth in earnings, together with low working capital turnover ratios, indicates new headwinds that could moderate the profitability and operating efficiency of the near term, which has burdened analyst sentiment and has been the basis of the rating downgrade.
The change in technical momentum has been a critical consideration in the decision to downgrade Maruti Suzuki, where the momentum was previously bullish but has changed to mildly bullish. Analysts have noted that on the weekly scale, the MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence) has become slightly bearish, whereas on the monthly scale, it is bullish. RSI indicators indicate a neutral/bearish position with respect to time, indicating the decline in the price strength.
Mixed trends in weekly and monthly charts are also observed in indicators like the Know Sure Thing (KST) oscillator and the Dow Theory indicators. Daily moving averages are encouraging, and the overall technical outlook does not suggest a high level of conviction, which indicates low near-term price movement. This decline in the technical signs has been one of the major causes of the change of rating to Hold.
Conclusion
The Buy to Hold downgrade of Maruti Suzuki India Ltd is a result of a balanced review, which considers not only the good long-term fundamentals but also new challenges that are coming up in the near future. Although the conservative financial structure, historical growth, and market leadership give the company a strong base, flat recent financial performance, possible working capital inefficiencies, and mixed technical indications are indicative that the stock may not provide the same impetus as it previously has.
The Hold rating reflects this optimistic caution as it appreciates the strengths of the company whilst reducing the expectations in shifting market conditions.
Read the full article here